Watchfulness, Prayer and Confession
A Homily by Elder Ephraim of Philotheou
My beloved children,
Today we will say a few things about the great virtue of watchfulness.
As you know, watchfulness is a patristic teaching, it is the experience of the
great neptic fathers of the Church and of the desert. The word "nepsis"
comes from "nepho," which means to be sleepless, to guard, to inspect,
examine, watch over, keep under surveillance. All these things the fathers sum
up in one continuous attention to the nous.
Watchfulness is described as the axe which shatters the large trees, hitting
their roots. And when the root is struck, it doesn’t spring up again. Thus also
when the nous of the man, of the Christian, has heed for the soul, it keeps
watch over the heart and the five senses of the soul, the bodily as well as the
spiritual. When the nous is awake, when it is attentive, when it keeps watch
over the speculations, the thoughts, when it controls the imagination, then the
whole man, body and soul, is kept pure. And when the man is rendered pure
through watchfulness and spiritual works, his prayers have boldness before God,
they cross the sky, they go beyond the stars, they pass through the heavens and
draw near to the Divine Throne of Grace, where the blessings of God are
granted. And this being the case, the man at prayer is enriched by the grace of
God.
The neptic fathers tell us that one of our thoughts may rise to heaven and
another may descend to hell. "By our thoughts we are improved or defiled." In
other words, a thought which may inattentively attack us, may pollute us, may
pleasure us, and is able to render us worthy of hell. A heavenly thought, a
thought of self-denial, a brave thought a thought of prayer and the vision of
God, makes us worthy to draw near the Divine throne and to taste of heavenly
things. By the thoughts either we will become unclean or we will become better.
The beginning of sins starts with the thoughts.
The thoughts come from the five senses, the spiritual as well as the physical.
When we allow the sense of sight to be uncontrolled and it carelessly sees
anything, this carelessness will become no end of dirty and sinful images.
Since these images are placed in the imagination, afterwards they drip the
poison of sinful pleasure inside the heart of man. This pleasure is the poison,
by which the heart is polluted and then becomes unclean and guilty before the
unsleeping eye of God.
Just like the sense of sight, so it is also of touch, and also of taste and
hearing and of smell. And so the five senses create analogous sinful images,
which render the man unclean before the face of God. Here rests the entire
philosophy of the spirit.
All sermons are beneficial, exactly because when a tree which is diseased is
pruned, it is cleansed, and thus the word of God helps in the reduction of a
passion. However, the teaching of the Fathers concerning watchfulness radically
effects the cleansing from the passions. When the mattock, when the axe strikes
the root, the entire tree falls down, it withers and is finished. So also when
watchfulness takes a place in the life of the Christian, a tree of passion
falls, it withers and thus in time, the old man, the man of sin and of passion,
the earthly Adam is freed and he becomes "a new man." For this reason, the
neptic work frees us radically from evil. Here then we must give heed to our
life. If we want to cleanse ourselves, we should make sure to enrich our nous
by the application of watchfulness.
A part of watchfulness is also noetic prayer. The vision of God is another part
of watchfulness. Spiritual warfare is also another part. All these parts, when
they are united in an effort of man, in time bring about holiness.
Abba Paphnoutios, a great desert father, was going along one day on his way and
there he saw two men committing some sin. The thought of his passion said:
"Look what great evil they are doing!" The eye saw them and immediately the
thought flared up, trying thereby to attack the purity of the Saint’s soul by
judging the brother or also by his being tempted. Having watchfulness, however,
he was being vigilant, immediately his mind was enlightened and he said to his
thought, "They are sinning today, I will sin tomorrow. They will repent, but I
know myself to be a hard man, unrepentant, egotistical, and thus, I won’t
repent. I will be punished since I am worse than these two. And what do I have
to do about these careless sinners, since I am a much greater sinner and more
passionate?" And speaking in this manner and putting a lock on the provocation
of sin, he was saved and didn’t judge the brothers who were sinning.
He didn’t go very far and an Angel of God appeared before him having a
double-edged cutless dripping blood; in other words, a knife which had cut from
both sides and he says to him:
"Paphnoutios, you see this knife? Do you see that it is dripping blood?"
"I see it Angel of God."
"With this knife I kill by taking the heads of the ones who judge their
neighbors. And since you didn’t judge, you didn’t condemn those who were in
fact sinning – not imagining or guessing that they were sinners, but seeing
them sin with your own eyes – but you condemned yourself more, for this reason
your name has been written in the book of eternal life."
Success. His name is written in eternal life, because he didn’t judge the
sinners, he didn’t condemn the sin of his brother. He would have judged if he
hadn’t had watchfulness, if he hadn’t been vigilant noetically in guarding his
soul. Do you see what good attention he produced? And do you see what harm he
would have suffered, if he had been inattentive to the thought and allowed it
to work within him! But his thought said that they were in fact sinning, he saw
them. In spite of these things, however, even though the thought was spoken to
him, the correct thought triumphed and thereby he escaped the shipwreck of his
soul.
All of the passions have their own images, their own fantasies and their own
pleasures. Murder has one image and another pleasure, gluttony has another and
so many other sinful passions have others. All of the pleasures are otherwise
poisons which bring about the death of the soul. We must take as our view that,
if we want to clean the "inside of the cup," the interior of the soul, our
heart, this center of man, we must strive to keep watchful. We should take care
to become better, that is, we should be vigilant to always have our hand on the
trigger. With the first appearance of the enemy, we should shoot. As soon as an
evil thought comes to us, immediately knock it down. A dirty image comes,
immediately spoil it. We shouldn’t allow it to become more vivid in colors and
in appearance, because thereby we will come to immediate difficulty. When the
evil is struck at the root, it is impossible to sprout and to increase. When
this struggle comes about with diligence, we will cleanse our soul and thereby
we will be found clean and with boldness before God.
A pagan priest asked some monks:
"Does your God appear to you? Do you see Him? Does he speak to you?
The fathers said:
"No."
The pagan says:
"If he doesn’t speak to you and doesn’t appear to you, this means that you
don’t have pure thoughts. When I pray, my God answers me.
Naturally, God didn’t answer the pagan, the demons answered him, but
nevertheless the fathers took it as an occasion of benefit and said:
"Indeed, the impure thoughts prevent man from communicating with God."
Watchfulness does nothing less than cleanse the nous and the heart from every
impurity. For this reason, with a little ascetical toil, watchfulness brings
about the greatest spiritual results. When we strive ascetically and aren’t
mindful of our thoughts, we accomplish nothing.
The Sacred Chrysostomos wrote many chapters about prayer and about wakefulness.
And in the midst of them he says something very beautiful: "Prayer," he
says, "is enlightenment of the soul, true consciousness of God, a mediator
between God and man, a physician of the passions, an antidote against diseases,
medicine against every illness, tranquility of the soul, a guide which carries
us to heaven, which doesn’t revolve around the earth, which marches towards the
apse of heaven. It passes over the buildings, it passes mentally through the
air, it walks above the air, it passes over the whole of the stars, it opens
the gates of heaven, it surpasses the angels, it transcends the Thrones and
Principalities, it passes over the Cherubim and when it has passed through all
of the foundation of nature, it comes near to the unapproachable Trinity. There
it worships the Divinity. There it is made worthy to become an interlocutor in
the Heavenly Kingdom. Through this (the prayer), the soul, which is lifted up
in the air to the heavens, embraces the Lord in an inexpressible manner,
exactly as the baby embraces its mother and with tears cries loudly, desiring
the enjoyment of divine milk. But it seeks the things which are necessary and
receives a gift superior to all visible nature.
Prayer is our venerable representative. It gladdens the heart. It gives rest to
the soul. It creates within us the fear of the punishment of hell, the desire
for the Kingdom of Heaven. It teaches humility, it grants awareness of sin and
in general it adorns man with every good thing, like a robe adorned with all
the virtues which enfolds the soul. It brought a gift to Anna, Samuel, and it
made known that Prophet of the Lord. This prayer also made Elias a zealot of
the Lord. And it became a guide for the descent of the heavenly fire for the
sacrifice. For while the priest of Baal was calling all day long to the idol,
he, after he lifted up his voice which came from his pure heart and cried out
through his mouth and his soul, the fire came down from heaven as a sign of the
righteousness of his prayer. Since he was standing like an eagle over the altar
with his fierce nature, he offered everything as a sacrifice. But the great
servant of God, the zealot Elias, did this, as all that happened then, teaching
us by the spirit, that we also crying loudly from the depths of our soul to
God, should move the ineffable fire of the Holy Spirit to come down to the
altar of our heart and to offer ourselves fully as a sacrifice to God."
All of the great fathers of the Church, especially the fathers of the desert,
succeeded in becoming worthy of great gifts exclusively and only with
watchfulness and vision of God [theoria]. Keeping vigil all night and
coming to the vision of the Light of God.
We have St. Gregory Palamas, the instructor of the desert, the instructor of
neptic activity, the teacher of noetic prayer. This saint would remain enclosed
in his cell for the entire week. He didn’t go outside at all. There on his
knees and with hands upraised, he was vigilant about his nous and his heart and
he received heavenly theology [literally "theology from above"—trans.]
by the Holy Spirit. The theology which made known the Uncreated Light of the
Divine Glory, of the Divine Nature.
The Uncreated Light is the glory of the Divine Nature. There was the goal and
the conclusion of asceticism and of prayer. When the saints received this
Light, they became all Light. And since the light floods the nous and the
heart, how could they know less than the mysteries of the secrets which are
known only to the angels? Through watchfulness the fathers attained to the
pinnacle of the virtues and of the graces.
And we, if we are watchful, if we pray, even if we are in the world, and even
if we don’t attain to similar states, no matter what, we will attain to a
condition of purity. When we succeed by watchfulness in not judging our
brother, this is no small achievement. We put into practice the commandment of
our Christ, which is as follows: "Do not judge, that you be not judged. For
with what judgment you judge, you shall be judged, and with what measure you
mete, it shall be measured to you" (Matt. 7:1-2).
It is the commandment of Christ. It is not the commandment of some Saint. It is
God’s. And therefore we have put into practice a Divine commandment. When we do
not judge, we will not be judged. Judge, and we will be judged. Sin is
widespread. Wherever we turn our eyes and our imagination, we recognize the
errors of men. Therefore, if we are inattentive, without watchfulness, we will
always be found in the error of violation of this evangelical commandment of
not judging our neighbor.
There was a monk in some monastery. The tempter had conquered him in
negligence. He didn’t do his canon, he didn’t got to church, he didn’t do his
rule of
prayer, and thus the fathers didn’t know him and regarded him as negligent. The
hour of death came and the fathers drew near him to see something, which
perhaps God would show, in order that they may be benefited. Drawing near to
the dying negligent monk, the fathers saw that he was very joyful. They were
perplexed and they said in their thoughts: "Look, why is he peaceful? The
negligence which he had in his life doesn’t worry him? What happened to the
debts which have been gathered because of sloth? His conscience doesn’t rebel?
It doesn’t make him worry? He doesn’t despair?" He continued to be
joyful. They compelled him to answer their question:
"Forgive us, brother, we see you doing so-so. We know and you know that you
lived in negligence and sloth in monastic duties. Now you are heading to the
judgment of Christ, and you should be somewhat sorry, worried, etc. But we see
you otherwise, joyful, peaceful, with hope and we question; what supports this
condition of yours?"
He answered them and said:
"You are right, my fathers, that’s how it is. I was negligent and didn’t do
what you did, but one thing I guarded in my life: not to judge my brother. I
read in the Holy Gospel, where the Lord says that the one who does not judge,
will not be judged. Thus I tried, at least, not to judge. And I hope in the
mercy of God that I will not be judged. For this reason I am departing with
faith that God will apply his word."
The fathers looked into it among themselves and said that in fact the brother
was very clever and masterfully gained his salvation.
If we are watchful, we will not criticize. For with the offense of judging,
immediately watchfulness will set up a barrier and the thought of judgment will
be prevented from continuing. Then will happen what took place with Abba
Paphnutios. And so we will escape from the sin of judging and of criticism of
the tongue and our names will be written in eternal life. A man who keeps his
tongue pure, both inner and outer, that is to say, the inner thought and the
tongue, and does this in the knowledge of God, this is a guarantee that he is
saved.
This spiritual attention becomes light and as light, illumines the path. And an
illumined path of watchfulness is also a path to sacred confession. The
attention illumines it, which urges the man to settle his account with God. And
he is guided by the light of watchfulness to this great mystery and there he
deposits the entire debt, all the uncleanness of sins. He enters into this bath
and he comes out entirely clean. And I say that we must have much joy in our
souls when we are accounted worthy to come into this bath. We must celebrate
and thank the Lord who allowed this bath on earth, who allowed this authority
of "binding and loosing." Whatever things your spiritual father looses, God
also looses. Whatever the representative of God forgives, the Lord also
forgives.
And when the man has been judged here below, he is not judged above in the
great and fearsome judgment. It is a great occasion if the man arrives as far
as that. For this reason, all those who have been accounted worthy of this bath
and continuously cleanse every soiling of the soul with this spiritual bath of
the mystery of God, should have very great joy, because the door of Paradise
will always be open. And even if death follows, there is no anxiety. "He is
prepared and not disturbed." When the man is prepared, he is not
disturbed at the approach of death. He knows that it is not possible for the
word of God, which gave this authority, to be wrong. We experience it as a
mystery of the Church and we see it in action and in application. When the man
makes sacred confession with ardent desire, with humility, and with awareness,
he feels the happiness within his soul, the lightness and the elation. A vivid
proof that his sins have been forgiven. And when sins are forgiven, then every
anxious and uncertain fear about the next life is removed.
Our thanks to God must be unceasing. Our thanksgiving must never stop, because
we are made worthy every time we want to receive this cleansing, and every time
we feel a sin, immediately turn the mind to God. "I have sinned Lord, forgive
me." With this "I have sinned Lord, forgive me," God answers:
"My child, you are forgiven; the power of the law is remitted. Proceed to the
application of the law." And the application is beneath the petraheli
(stole). There all the sinfulness of man is ended. Forgiveness is so easy! It
is very wrong for man, when this forgiveness is so easy and so free, because of
his egoism not to want to receive it, not to want to open the doors of paradise
and walk eternally in the glory of God!
Many men say: "Man should call upon God because of one sin?" But this thing is
wrong. Where is the love of God? Isn’t God a father?" Yes, he is a
father, but when every good moment comes for him to forgive you, why do you
turn your back? Why do you not receive His mercy? Why do you refuse His embrace
and go far away? Why do you accept the embrace of the devil and not of God?
Perhaps your god seeks money or possessions or favors and you don’t have all
these things and for this reason you don’t come to let go of your debt? No.
God is very rich, as we see also in the parable of the prodigal. The prodigal
wanted to depart far away. He demanded that part of the possessions which
belonged to him. And God gave him what he was owed as physical gifts. He didn’t
deprive him of them. However, he squandered these gifts, the spiritual
possessions, living prodigally. And when he arrived at the wretched end, he
came to his senses, he came to himself. For he was not himself when all the
prodigality reigned. And when he came to himself he said: "How many serve my
father and they enjoy the good things of His possessions, and I His child, par
excellence His child, am in such misery that I graze pigs and am allotted
husks! I will return; He is a Father, He will receive me. I will ask
forgiveness and will say to him, do not receive me as Your child, neither
restore me to the first adoption, but I will ask him to become one of His
servants. And this will be a great thing."
When he thought these things, already the Father came out from His house and
waited for him with open arms. He accepted him with all his heart and all his
soul. He embraced him, he kissed him, he wept from joy, because he was dead and
he was restored to life, he was lost and was found. He made him His child again
with all of the wealth. He forgave everything. He cleansed him of every filth.
He clothed him in the original garments. In the end, he gave him everything.
The Heavenly Father also does this when one who is a sinner returns to Him. He
cleanses him, washes him, he gives the original garments of baptism, he gives
him sonship and makes him worthy of His Kingdom. Everything free. When the
prodigal returned, he didn’t seek an account, neither did he rebuke him nor did
he seek to blame him. He begins where he returned; this was sufficient for the
Father. Only to say "sinner," to leave his sins with humility, to understand
his mistakes and from then on everything is loosed. But the sinful man doesn’t
do this. He doesn’t return, he isn’t humbled. He holds on to his egoism. The
important thing is to get to the confessional! It’s two steps. And from then on
everything is finished. Yet the tears of egoism hold him. And when he comes to
the hour of death and the reality of it, then he will repent and he will be
remorseful, but he will be too late. In this, God respects the one who doesn’t
want to humble his spirit a little.
As for Lucifer, this great battalion commander, who was in the first place of
the angelic hosts, what was the cause of the fall? What was the cause of the
collapse, of the transformation from angels to demons? Pride and egoism. The
error came from these. And as with the angels, so also with our forebears. The
fall of our forebears came about from pride and egoism. Because, before God
accomplished the verdict of guilt, he approached the man Adam and said to him:
"Adam, why did you do this?’ Adam didn’t seek forgiveness, he didn’t
say: "God forbid, I was wrong." If he had done this, he wouldn’t have
been turned out from Paradise and neither would we have all this banishment and
suffering today. By not saying "God forbid" all this mob of evil came
about. And thus now man doesn’t say "God forbid" and remains in his
evil. But just say it, O God stretch out the arms of forgiveness, and he takes
him in.
And again I say that because we have been made worthy to know as Orthodox
Christians this mystery of sacred confession, we should have very great joy,
because even if any time we fall down in some sin, into something evil, we can
run immediately to correct it and to preserve the health of our souls. And when
death comes, we will go to meet the Lord, cleansed, repentant, as prodigal sons
returned, for our Heavenly Father accepts us and places us in the Paradise of
eternal bliss which has no end, which has no conclusion to that bliss, which
cannot be compared to anything earthly.
And even the Apostle Paul, who went up to the third heaven and saw the eternal
good things, nevertheless was unable with his apostolic and graceful tongue to
express with human words, the things of Paradise and the life above! So
inexpressible is the happiness of the attainment through sacred confession.
Therefore with much yearning, with much love, with much awareness we should run
to be cleansed, to be made ready and when death follows, to depart in peace.
Amen.
Translated from the Greek by Fr. Seraphim Bell, pastor of St.
Silouan the Athonite Orthodox Church in Walla Walla, WA. This was Homily 12
from The Art of Salvation [in Greek], Vol A.
+ + +
Father Seraphim Bell Responds to a Reader's Criticism of this Homily
An Orthodox Christian who read this homily wrote to the Orthodox Christian Information Center the following:
The article on Nepsis seemed very gooduntil we reach certain aspects of the mythology of a meeting with "the Angel of God":
"He didn't go very far and an Angel of God appeared before him having a double-edged cutless dripping
blood; in other words, a knife which had cut from both sides and he says to him:
'Paphnoutios, you see this knife? Do you see that it is dripping blood?'
'I see it Angel of God.'
'With this knife I kill by taking the heads of the ones who judge their neighbors...'"
This supposed incident is so far removed from anything in our fathers' or mothers' teachings
that it reveals the skewered view of "god" as a vengeful, pagan god who requires blood from
sinners (i.e. Latin influence of Atonement theory perhaps). This view of God has a place in
Calvinismand Augustinianismbut certainly is not how God has revealed Himself to us in
Holy Scriptures and in the Person of Christ Jesus!
"Nepsis" requires us to Watch AND beware of false prophets!
I sent this comment to Father Seraphim Bell. He replied as follows:
I know this woman. ____ approaches our Holy Tradition in a very Western rationalistic way.
She is a literalist. As she passes through the meadow of Holy Tradition, whenever she trips over
the flowers of this Tradition, she simply uproots them. And in this way, she believes she actually
upholds the Tradition.
Her treatment of our holy Father Paphnoutious is but one example. The vision offends her
mind and so she deals with it in a very carnal, rationalistic manner. She discards it. And
she does so in the name of the Tradition which she is mutilating.
St. Makarios once had a vision of Satan walking about with a feather. St. Makarios asked
him what he was doing with the feather and he replied that he used it to tickle the monks to
sleep. Now ____ would read that and believe that we are being told that Satan has a literal
feather and actually tickles monks with it. Since such a thing is nonsense to her carnal mind,
she would refer to this as a "supposed incident" and declare unilaterally that it is "so far
removed from anything in our fathers' or mothers' teachings..."
St. Anthony once had a vision in which he saw Satan setting so many terrible traps for mankind
that one couldn't take one step without falling into them. He despaired and cried out to God,
"if this is how it is, how can anyone be saved?" ____, if she is to be consistent, would take
this in a literalist fashion and it would offend her carnal mind, and so she must reject it.
Does she think that Satan actually set those mechanical traps that Anthony saw? She seems
incapable of understanding the spiritual nature of visions which our holy Fathers have had and
the purpose for them.
Even though blessed Fr. Seraphim Rose warns his readers not to think in a literal rationalistic
manner about tollhouses, ____ ignores this warning and falls into the trap that Fr. Seraphim sought
to warn her about.
Of course Satan doesn't have a literal physical feather, nor does he set actual mechanical
traps for us. Nor does an angel go about with a real physcial sword, dripping with blood,
beheading individuals. Nor are there actual booths in the sky with demons exacting a toll.
She misses entirely the spiritual nature of these visions and their intent. Each one is meant
to lead us to watchfulness, to humility, to self-criticism, to repentance, etc. Each vision is
startling, dramatic, unearthly and acts powerfully upon the saint to impress upon him these
spiritual realities as realities!
But spiritual realities offend this woman's carnal mind and so she rejects them. She pretends not only
that our Holy Father Paphnoutios did not have such a vision, but that such a thing is completely
foreign to "our fathers' or mothers' teachings," when in reality, such things permeate the Holy
Tradition. By implication, anyone who passes on this Tradition is a "false prophet" (because
she says so!).
What is foreign to "our fathers' or mothers' teachings" is her arbitrary picking and choosing
among the meadow of Patristic writings. She can accept only what her rational mind allows her to
accept. She sets herself as judge of the Tradition, which is typical of American Catholics and
Protestants. She has yet to be converted to an Orthodox mind.
For this reason, as with so many Catholics and Protestants, Orthodox spirituality is a fascinating
and scintillating theory for her. But she remains far from entering into its reality.
Fr. Seraphim
Reply posted on 26 March 2006.
|